Value of biodiversity the environmental literacy council. The value of biodiversity can be separated into two categories. Intrinsic value or inherent worth is what makes trees, species, and ecosystems the subjects of direct moral concern in the minds of many environmental ethicists, so its importance to the field can hardly be overstated. Biodiversity means variety of flora and fauna in the world or in a particular habitat. An ethics of biodiversity georgetown university press. The role of ethics and values in indias biodiversity conservation. Besides all forms of life have a right to exist on the earth. Utilitarian, deontological, biocentric, ecocentric, and feminist ethical ways of thinking about biodiversity loss may lead to different conclusions about duties to preserve plants, animals, and ecosystems. Apart from the economic importance of conserving biodiversity, there are several cultural, moral and. The recent may 1998 conference of the parties on biodiversity in bratislava has. This project aims at examining the role that ethics and environmental values play in shaping. Our understanding of ethics and biodiversity is still in its infancy, yet it is advancing. Anthropocentric value is comprised of direct and indirect economic benefit to humans and ethical.
The multiple uses of biodiversity or biodiversity value has been classified by mcneely et al. Ethics would come in picture for the human actions impacting biodiversity. Human cultures coevolve with their environment, and therefore the conservation of biological diversity can also be important for cultural identity. But, regarding the details, the question of how biodiversity can be understood in a practical manner and what the principles and. That is, people dont have the right to destroy species and should take. The primary ethical challenge we face in protecting and improving earths biodiversity is human disregard for the intrinsic value of biodiversity. These reasons are often part of a comprehensive ethical or cosmological world view that, on the one hand, is anchored in a selfconception or identity and, on the other hand, is supported by an interpretative tradition and the communities that share it. Ethical values differ from place to place, culture to culture, time to time and differ between different components of biodiversity. Oct 17, 2016 biodiversity means variety of flora and fauna in the world or in a particular habitat.
Very often, people value biodiversity for ethical and religious reasons. Despite these ethical issues, many consider the ecosystem services concept to have the capacity of highlighting the critical role ecosystems and biodiversity play in sustaining life, human wellbeing and longterm economic sustainability costanza and daly, 1992, teeb the economics of ecosystems and biodiversity. We know that, because our very lives and our economies are dependent upon biodiversity. Some of the classifications of biodiversity value are. Associate professor, department of agricultural and resource economics, university of california, berkeley, california.
The problem of measuring biodiversity is compounded by ones involved in measuring both stability and productivity, leading to extended controversy among theorists in the 1990s described in sarkar 2005. Indirect values would include ethical or moral value, existence value, ecological value, aesthetic value, cultural or spiritual value, option value and scientific or educational value. Loss of biodiversity raises the ethical question of human responsibility to protect plants and animals. If, as the signatures suggest, the nonscientists can be persuaded without a real argument and a hundred thousand. As part of a typology of paradigmatic approaches in todays ethics of nature. Human cultures coevolve with their environment, and. Aanalysis of the value of preserving biodiversity requires. Anthropocentric value is comprised of direct and indirect economic benefit to humans and ethical value is based on a respect for life, a reverence for the living world and a sense of intrinsic value in nature and a concept of divine creation. As part of a short biodiversity unit, a survey was developed for students to express their ethical values regarding conservation of biodiversity or.
Chapter 6 discounting, ethics, and options for maintaining. For example, easy access to genetic resources for breeding purposes is important, but international agreements and legal frameworks are necessary to ensure adequate recognition of the contributions of local. Species interact in complex ways in biological communities. Chapter 5 the economics of valuing ecosystem services and. Each question was first read aloud and students could ask for clarification. Dec 15, 2014 before engagement began, students participated in the anonymous ethical survey on values and beliefs they hold regarding biodiversity. Biodiversity conservation different methods and strategies. Deliberative and critical ethical questions and their relationship to the value dimension of the decisionmaking process in educational administration by shaffer, edward o. Ethical considerations regarding the collecting, research, and use of agricultural biodiversity are currently topics of great concern. The biosphere comprises of a complex collection of innumerable organisms, known as the. That is, people dont have the right to destroy species and should take action to prevent their extinction. Aug 20, 2011 indirect values would include ethical or moral value, existence value, ecological value, aesthetic value, cultural or spiritual value, option value and scientific or educational value. Ethical considerations in agrobiodiversity research.
Cultural values the cultural value of biological diversity conservation for present and future generations is an important reason for conserving it today. Angela mary binoy annies minu sathiyaseelan brijita chaudhary ashwini utturkar 2. An ethics of biodiversity not only lays out the arguments and criticisms around the ecological values in biodiversity, but also lays out theological arguments for biodiversity as having sacramental value. The value of biodiversity concepts about the value of nature value of wildlife for sport hunters for tourists bioprospecting uncertain benefits ecotourism what is payed for. Biodiversity conservation has three main objectives. The quebec biodiversity website examines different arguments used in discussions over conserving biodiversity, explaining both intrisic value and ecosystem services. Since man is the most intelligent amongst the living organisms, it should be prime responsibility and moral obligation of man to preserve and conserve other organisms, which will directly or indirectly favour the existence of the man.
The ethical dimensions of global environmental issues. There is a need to bring ethicists, scientists, and biodiversity managers together in a collaborative effort to study and inform the methods of ethical analysis and problem solving in ecological. Biodiversity must be seen in the light of holding ethical value. As you learned in the science section, biodiversity is essential to the wellbeing of earths inhabitants and is the manifestation our planets incredible variety. Since man is the most intelligent amongst the living organisms, it should be prime responsibility and moral obligation of man to preserve and. The individual components of biodiversitygenes, species, and ecosystemsprovide society with a wide array of goods and services.
The value of biodiversity encyclopedia of life support. It is the summed value of all the gnps of all countries from now until the end of the world. But, regarding the details, the question of how biodiversity can be understood in a practical manner and what the principles and criteria are necessary to judge and assess the value of biodiversity, is still very much in the dark. The value of biodiversity is the value of everything there is. Negative impacts of economic growth include unsustainable conversion, use and exploitation of terrestrial, freshwater and marine ecosystems and resources, which threaten biodiversity and degrade natures contributions to people by reducing species abundances below selfsustaining levels. Pdf the moral value of biodiversity markku oksanen. The year 2010 has long been seen as an end goal, a time when we could look back and say, yes, weve done it that biodiversity, life on earth, is no longer threatened. Pdf ethics of wildlife management and conservation. Pdf the convention on biological diversity emerged out of a universal consensus that biodiversity is of immense value to humankind. Humans have a duty to protect species, biological communities and other aspects of biodiversity based on their intrinsic value. The concept of biodiversity as revealing god to us is powerful, even as obrien validates the many questions about the goodness of. For example, the ethical value attached to sacred basil is not accorded to cactus in india. Values of biodiversity economic value the economic potential of biodiversity is immense in terms of food, medicinal, ethical and social values. Ethics and climate change in asia and the pacific eccap project working group 16.
Because utilitarians recognize only the intrinsic value of pleasure or desire satisfaction, the commitment to intrinsic value. In this section, we explore the ethical challenges involving biodiversity. Discounting, ethics, and options for maintaining biodiversity and ecosystem integrity 3 key messages there are no purely economic guidelines for choosing a discount rate. Social values social value of biodiversity lies in the more and more use of resources by affluent societies. Andreozzi, against those environmental ethicists who deny biodiversity any intrinsic value, analyzes the distinct meanings that the concept of intrinsic value can have, concluding that biodiversity can be seen as having an intrinsic value according to one of these possible understandings, and that ascribing intrinsic value to biodiversity. Biodiversity or biological diversity, refers to the range of life forms on earth. To maintain lifesupporting systems and essential ecological processes. To address the ethical challenges of earths declining biodiversity, we return to the three foundations of healing earths environmental ethic the study and practice of actions that contribute to the wellbeing. Genes, species, and ecosystems of direct, indirect, or potential use to humanity are often referred to as biological resources mcneely and others 1990. Ethical values differ from place to place, culture to culture, time to time and differ. Apr 18, 2010 ethical considerations regarding the collecting, research, and use of agricultural biodiversity are currently topics of great concern. Some argue that it is our moral responsibility to preserve the earths incredible diversity for the next generation. Alongside biodiversity, field research has concentrated on two other features. The problem of measuring biodiversity is compounded by ones involved in.
Moral consequences and implications arise here for mans dealings with biodiversity. Environmental ethics is the discipline in philosophy that studies the moral relationship of human beings to, and also the value and moral status of, the environment and its nonhuman contents. Before engagement began, students participated in the anonymous ethical survey on values and beliefs they hold regarding biodiversity. Genes, species, and ecosystems of direct, indirect, or potential use to. Environmental ethics stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Biodiversity functions in public and policy discourse not merely descriptively but also prescriptively. These characteristics help us understand and respect the intrinsic value of biodiversity.
Biodiversity has a fundamental value to humans because we are so dependent on it for our cultural, economic, and environmental wellbeing. The economics of valuing ecosystem services and biodiversity 5 1 introduction economics, as the study of how to allocate limited resources, relies on valuation to provide society with information. Examination of the common goals to protect and value biodiversity over. The economics of valuing ecosystem services and biodiversity 5 1 introduction economics, as the study of how to allocate limited resources, relies on valuation to provide society with information about the relative level of resource scarcity. The biodiversity heritage library works collaboratively to make biodiversity literature openly available to the world as part of a global biodiversity community. This was a 15question survey focusing on ethical questions, values, and judgments, and it was repeated at the end of the unit. Intrinsic value or inherent worth is what makes trees, species, and ecosystems the subjects of direct moral concern in the minds of many environmental ethicists, so its importance to the field can hardly. Biodiversity is considered to have great value on cultural and religious grounds specially in india and east asian countries. The values of biodiversity the national academies press. Biodiversity conservation is the protection and management of biodiversity to obtain resources for sustainable development. Environmental ethics biodiversity preservation stanford. Apart from the economic importance of conserving biodiversity, there are several cultural, moral and ethical values which. Valuing biodiversity, lesson 1 and 2 flashcards quizlet. The biosphere comprises of a complex collection of innumerable organisms, known as the biodiversity which constitutes the vital life support for the survival of human race includes millions of plants animals and micro organisms,the genes they contain and the ecosystems of which.
977 345 473 608 246 1280 302 507 233 228 96 252 913 923 474 1294 762 1068 880 754 672 736 770 262 666 79 1304 890